Remove Necroposting Rule from Suggestions


Go to page: 1 Bookmark Thread
Kittykat

12:42am Oct 14 2014 (last edited on 12:48am Oct 14 2014)

Normal User


Posts: 1,477

There are quite a lot of suggestions currently in this here suggestions forum.
Problem is that, if we try to support any of these brilliant ideas now (excluding like, 6 posts that are within 4 weeks), they get locked and eventually removed for Necroposting, and that glorious suggestion that could have one day become reality, is gone.

There are definitely some excellent suggestions in this forum category as a whole, but alas can't be heard long enough or supported because we cannot post on them after 4 weeks, because that would be necroposting, which I find personally, rather annoying and literally silly.

Suggestions are here for attention and feedback; something to build upon and one day produce, yes?

Which is why I propose that the Necroposting rule does not count for the Suggestions Forums. Or maybe even expand the time limit to a year or so to give older suggestions a chance to be reheard.
The Necroposting rule currently isn't in place for Site Feedback, and suggestions, to me, is another form of site feedback, where we think of things to add to, and improve on around the site. And frankly, there's no real point making a suggestion if it's only going to be active for a month and then be unable to post on it and get ignored altogether. 

Thoughts? c:
PreviousBlue

1:00pm Oct 14 2014

Normal User


Posts: 611
Glad to know someone else feels the same way 
Owly

5:42am Oct 15 2014

Normal User


Posts: 708
(a suggestion for the suggestions forum this is great)
nevertheless, i support all the way.
Zen

3:01am Oct 16 2014

Artist


Posts: 3,187
I think I saw a discussion on this before and the argument was:
It helps to weed out unpopular suggestions.

or something like that

which I can understand and you can always ask a Support member to unlock your thread again

BUT 

I support removing the rule for suggestions, or at least extending the "active" time.

It seems that many people don't look at the suggestions, or if they like a suggest simply don't comment (or at least that's what I've gathered when a conversation about it came up) 

weeks later someone could think of something to add 
the poster could think of something to add
... it's early and im still not thinking clearly so im sure there's a lot more to add to this.
Llama

5:26am Oct 16 2014

Normal User


Posts: 777
To me I would be happy if we had a similar structure to fan clubs where there is no necroposting rule but there is only one thread related to a specific issue with users being able to build upon, bump up or offer similar suggestions
jayni

7:23am Oct 19 2014

Normal User


Posts: 1,100
Support
Lilith

2:10pm Oct 20 2014

Moderator


Posts: 2,153
I don't see a problem with removing the necroposting rule for suggestions. It was in place before mainly to discourage bumping bad ideas that had died off when we didn't have the manpower in place to do forum maintenance. We do have the manpower for forum maintenance now, so anything that doesn't need to be revived could just be locked so that it isn't able to be posted on. That's my view anyhow. 

Thoughts??



＊*•̩̩͙✩•̩̩͙*˚♫ and the haters gonna hate hate hate hate hate ♫＊*•̩̩͙✩•̩̩͙*˚
Flammable

9:27pm Oct 20 2014

Normal User


Posts: 156
IMO the necroposting rule in general could use some rethinking. Is a four week limit really appropriate for forums as slow as these? It looks like in most of the forums only about 1/3 of the first page falls under this limit.
RainofStars

11:45pm Oct 22 2014 (last edited on 11:46pm Oct 22 2014)

Normal User


Posts: 854
Complete support.

I suggested the same thing: http://www.rescreatu.com/forum/cat/feedback/suggestions/no-expiration-on-threads-in-suggestions-forum/~page/1/

..but it's an old thread so of course you're not allowed to post on it any more. ;) The irony.


Buying foods that Vegeta has not eaten!
Kittykat

12:29am Oct 23 2014

Normal User


Posts: 1,477
Thank you guys for the support!!
Haha indeed Rain!!
crowflux

4:11am Oct 23 2014

Administrator


Posts: 333
I feel this way about necroposting in general on our forums. In its current state, the rule is not encouraging new activity. 

At the very least right now, removing the necroposting rule should be the case for Suggestions. :)
Kittykat

1:59am Nov 5 2014

Normal User


Posts: 1,477
bumps
Unicorn

9:06pm Nov 11 2014

Normal User


Posts: 2,056
Support!!


RAINBOWS and STUFF
Kirby

5:06pm Dec 4 2014

Normal User


Posts: 841
Support <3
Kittykat

1:56am Dec 22 2014

Normal User


Posts: 1,477
thank ya'll ;v;
GreenKat

7:08pm Feb 21 2015

Normal User


Posts: 3,163
Support <3 

...

this better not be locked if this post is too old
Go to page: 1