I'm not sure that I'm posting this in the correct place, but I really need some help. I have been reading all of the newbie guides and help pages but I think I'm still doing something wrong. I tried to complete the squishy quest... and had all the squishys that he was asking for but I wasn't sure how to turn it in so the time ran out and the quest started over. Please help me out and thank you in advance. I'm also very sorry that this is a newbie question. 

When you have collected the correct items you return to the quest and there will be a button for you to click to give the NPC your items.

Weird. That never happened. Maybe I had the wrong items. I thought they were right. lol. I'll keep an eye out for that next time. Thank you soooooo much! :) 

A good way to make sure you get the right items is to keep the quest page open and copy and paste each of the names of the items. ^^