To Crunch Or Not To Crunch


Go to page: 1 Bookmark Thread
StFangofBoredom

12:56am Mar 9 2011 (last edited on 12:57am Mar 9 2011)

Normal User


Posts: 65

So, I've got this ongoing debate...

I wrote this Poem for my Creative Writing course last semester and got mixed reviews on it.  So I'd like some things cleared up.

 Here's the poem.

The Autumn Ballet

 Spinning and twirling,

Faster and faster,
The wind catches.

Floating and falling,
Flipping and flying,
Skids along the trunk.

Flashes of red and orange.
Madly dancing with the air.

Nature's graceful ballet.
Ends when it finally touches the ground.

Crunch.

One clomping boot and this dancer is done. 

 http://fang-not-fnick.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d318wf9 = Link to it on dA.

 

Now, the debate:

 Many people, including my teacher thought that I should take out the last two lines where the leaf gets crunched and end it at 'Ends when it finally touches the ground.'

Now, I like it the way it is.  I thin taking out those last two lines leaves it feeling...Unfinished.  Though I doubt I'll change it, I would like some other opinions for future reference an such.  Agree?  Disagree?  Any other ideas on this poem? 

Thanks!

-Saint 

NightmareDream

3:38pm Mar 9 2011

Normal User


Posts: 1,551
I think it should end at "ends when it finally touches the ground", but I don't think you need to crunch it. ^^ There's my vote. 



Go to page: 1