Critique my poetry?


Go to page: 1, 2 Bookmark Thread
PeasOnEarth

10:18pm Sep 19 2011 (last edited on 5:33pm Nov 5 2011)

Normal User


Posts: 198
nevermind about the critic thing. you can still leave your opinion here, if you like.
i'm just going to post some poems every now and then when i have the creativity to do so.


please keep in mind that some of these may be a work in progress or just general ideas for poems that i will write one day.




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

10:20pm Sep 19 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
What is out there for you
ragged razor shoes and big brown eyes
a sliver of silver lighting
which is hiding in your forest

I am looking under rocks
and chopping down trees
littering the floor
with pine needles
shoes that stomp on
fragile bees

you slow down your breathing
and ask 'what is out there for me'
collecting the drops of rain
because you would only ever do that
if you were really in pain

It's there I'll find you-
saying goodbye to the ground
blowing on dandelion wishes
with pockets full of stones

(and then you jump)

I'll find myself asking
'what is out there for you'

you will sleep on top of ambition
while the forest dies away
and when I leave,
build up bridges

I will sit next to you
far after the silver lighting fled
wondering
if anything was ever out there to begin with




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

10:21pm Sep 19 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
a black dog follows me
and it doesn't bother me anymore.
he's waiting for me
and waiting
and waiting.

i want to write something,
something about myself.
but i think i've run out of things to say.
i'm still walking and i'm alive
and i think, "i'm okay, this is ok."

and sometimes i can feel him.
it's early in the morning
and i think, "i'll be ok"
and i'll walk down the road
step,
after step,
and during that silence
he reminds me of how alone I am.

or when i sit on the floor of the cafeteria
watching everyone else be happy
and they all talk, but-
i just here how quiet it is,
and he'll watch me with those
black eyes and just wait for me.

a few people will walk by
and they look so happy
and i'll think, "this isn't okay."
but i won't do anything
and the dog waits some more.




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

10:26pm Sep 19 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
Horrid heart was found dead
With an unhealthy attachment
We can't save a hole that's stained red
(A heartless void is an advancement)
It fades away on the side of a road
Hollow hands and frozen fingers
And all
With threads pulled and slowed
It's affection lingers
Though you remember as well as I do
We both knew to know never
A heart's hole can not renew
Can not last whatsoever


bleh, rhyming.




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

10:30pm Sep 19 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
dark overlaps white
when death creeks in the floorboards.
tonight we all have stage fright
when you're tangled in the cords.
voices can't break through
because your lungs no longer strive.
your mouth can't even speak true!
you're barely alive!
a soundless crack caused the scene
in a place miles from home,
where you were once- only eighteen,
never stepping outside your own screen.
your breath slowly slides away
out of a white spot automatically.
losing thought, screaming your final day,
and the stars twinkled all dramatically.
the wicked misery after death
with a selfish song lost in the fray.
you breathe no more breath-
vision fading to gray.




Banner by Zerr.
NightmareDream

12:47pm Sep 20 2011

Normal User


Posts: 1,551
 I liked your first two poems that you posted the best. The first one was very good, in that you had great "camera angles". Meaning that you would focus on an image, then a sound, then a feeling-- bit by bit. And you do that well. You had an active voice, which is nice. The general mood of the poem was good. You even had some rhyme and rhythm, but it didn't read as forced, and all it did was add to the poem. Not take away. 

Speaking of rhyme, whenever you add rhyme in a poem, you always must ask whether or not adding in the rhyme will make your poem better, or whether or not it will simply take away from what you're trying to say. This is why I liked your first two poems the best. I felt that the other poems were interesting, but they weren't as good because the rhyming made the sentences awkward at times, and made it feel as though it were forced. 

Anyway, back to the first poem.. the only downside to that one was the actual meaning of it. It's one of those poems that you like (despite it being kind of abstract), and you say to yourself, "This sounded nice, and I think I kind of got the essence of what it was saying." But you don't ever really know. It was well written, but you must make sure that what the poem is saying makes sense to other people as well. Other people don't really know what was going on in your brain when you wrote it, so the meaning might not be so clear in their minds as it is yours. 

Actually, that's the one downside to writing an abstract poem-- the possibility that others might not really get it in the end, even though it sounds nice and the mood is there.

The second poem was also well written, although it didn't have as many pretty images as the first one, but it seemed easier to understand. Though the meaning still was kind of unclear. 

I think your poems are lovely. ^^ And I'm picky when it comes to poetry. :)  



PeasOnEarth

8:18pm Sep 20 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
Wow. Thanks so much for your feedback. If you feel that I'm slightly well with "camera angles" then I guess I'm going to start focusing on that to develop it more. Rhyming is definitely something I've never been able to accomplish so I'm not so worried about that. I'm not even going to try with that anymore.

I never noticed those awkward lines before but now that you pointed it out, I think I understand what you mean. Honestly, the first two poems are newer pieces I've constructed and I'm really glad you liked them, even if only a small bit. Thank you.




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

8:19pm Sep 20 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
I wrote this yesterday but I forgot to post. SO AFTER this poem I'll get working on my strong points:

she said to me
'i didn't think i'd see you again'
but she knows i have medicine for that
and i'm happy
and happy
and i'm so happy.

happiness brings me closer to God
in a language she can't speak
but i'm awake
alive
with trembling hands and tied breath

if i could
i'd ask her how the weather was
because i know that she's lonely
and i'm happy
and happy
and i'm so happy.

i'll be waiting for this sleep
this malice past the divide
so leave my body where it lies
because she's lonely
but she's awake
alive.




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

3:47pm Sep 25 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
i feel as if this one was written very poorly even though i tried very hard to convey my emotions. i may go back and edit this:

i'll be waiting
to pull this thread
and rip the skin from around your neck

because there's flowers in your spine.

i'll find you
deep down in your rib cage,
lightly pulling the breath from your lungs
and wondering about the importance of your life.
your oxygen tank is running on empty.

God stole what was left of your bones
and now you can't remember
how to walk
how to laugh
how to smile
because every time you stand,
something tumbles down
(and it's not your spinal chord).

it appears you've ran out of thread.

do you count as dead
if you're just sick of living?
i can't say you're very much alive
anymore.




Banner by Zerr.
NightmareDream

3:24pm Sep 29 2011

Normal User


Posts: 1,551
Bump for you. ;)



PeasOnEarth

4:57pm Sep 29 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
thank you.




Banner by Zerr.
Ensei

2:22pm Oct 1 2011

Normal User


Posts: 35
I would love to read your poetry and help you with it!  I think writing is so much fun.



I love you, Zack Fair. Rest in Peace.
PeasOnEarth

4:01pm Oct 8 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
too bad you can't really make a living off of writing. lol.




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

6:06pm Nov 1 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
i want you to be there
when the sky stops spinning
and the trees simply shake.

we will suddenly die.

feeding the earth with our bodies
and empty thoughts chilling
the dead dark dirt.

this is not how you had hoped.

sometimes people die alone,
but not us.
we will grow flowers here
in our void company.




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

5:49am Nov 4 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
this is really bad and kind of vented:

i am not your enemy.

i won't let you down
because we live in this moment
and the sun is shining,
right?

i once saw you under,
and now i think about you everyday
because my lungs burn
with sympathy.

i wish you were more passionate.

i want to help you,
but i'm not going to teach someone
who never even tried.

you care, though.




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

5:31pm Nov 5 2011 (last edited on 5:59pm Nov 5 2011)

Normal User


Posts: 198

hey,
listen.
don't eat your
heart out for this.
you don't deserve to
be sad. i don't want to
know that you're slowly killing
yourself, because i know
that yes, people die,
but it is not
your day. at
least for
now.




Banner by Zerr.
PeasOnEarth

7:05pm Nov 6 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
you push me away
but my lungs burn forward.

here we are again.

you don't give me enough credit
for the things we do best
and i know that i can be more

we will never rest
no, not until after our war
so give me this chance

let me be more.




Banner by Zerr.
YoursTruly

6:55pm Nov 8 2011

Normal User


Posts: 3,809
I like the last one, but the rhyming sequences seem a littly iffy to me. The syllables and the fact only parts of it rhyme kinda bug me, but I don't often read mixed poems. Normally it's either almost all rhyme or almost all non-rhyme. ^ _^"



Well now. I should... Probably put something intelligent here. At some point. Eventually.
...
... Screw it. HYE. ♥
PeasOnEarth

7:37pm Nov 10 2011

Normal User


Posts: 198
i see what you mean.
i'll try to fix it but, eh. ;p




Banner by Zerr.
Ping

5:33am Nov 21 2011

Normal User


Posts: 1,775
I read your first poem and I have a few issues with it.
The main one being that you have no set rhyme scheme. It's okay to have free verse, but you seem to want to rhyme and not rhyme at the same time. It'sconfusing and sounds bad when you read it out loud.

'What is out there for you
ragged razor shoes and big brown eyes
a sliver of silver lighting
which is hiding in your forest

I am looking under rocks
and chopping down trees
littering the floor
with pine needles
shoes that stomp on
fragile bees

you slow down your breathing
and ask 'what is out there for me'
collecting the drops of rain
because you would only ever do that
if you were really in pain

It's there I'll find you-
saying goodbye to the ground
blowing on dandelion wishes
with pockets full of stones

(and then you jump)

I'll find myself asking
'what is out there for you'

you will sleep on top of ambition
while the forest dies away
and when I leave,
build up bridges

I will sit next to you
far after the silver lighting fled
wondering
if anything was ever out there to begin with'

                                                
You make rhymes in two of the stanzas and you just stop rhyming. When it's read out loud, it just sounds bad.

I can point out that 'what is out there for you' is grammatically a question. When you read it out loud, it's like you have to use intonation (as in you must stress the word 'is'). Sure thing, you can claim you can use the poetic licence, but I don't like it when people do anyways. It doesn't sound right.

The poem as well doesn't flow very nicely. You just jump from place to place. You question something in the beginnning and then just say 'ragged razor shoes and big brown eyes / a sliver of silver lighting / which is hiding in your forest'. Which is completely irrelevant. There is no purpose for mentioning these shoes, lightning and the forest.

Then you take a tour of the forest. No idea why, you don't mention why. You search for something, you don't mention why and you never reveal the significance of embarking on this search. I have a feeling you are looking for 'what is our there for you'. But that doesn't really make any sense. Who is 'you' what is the thing that is 'out there'. What does it represent? There is a lot of repetition of 'what is out there for you' but I don't even know what it means. You also say 'it's there I'll find you', but you haven't made where 'there' is clear.

It's not that I hate the poem or anything. You need to make things clearer. I find that things are too vague and the whole poem is difficult ot understand and unmoving. It's not very good if your poem is unmoving. If you need to explain what this poem actually means to mean, by all means do. I can help and offer advice to make your second draft better.

I haven't read the rest of the poems, I will read them and offer crits if you want me to.




I (HATE)' YOU

Feel the love man D:<

Go to page: 1, 2